I will start with the most straightforward but most controversial for cooking methods. Wait; I know you are thinking how can cooking a steak be that difficult? You simply cook it to the desired level of doneness and eat right? Well yes and no. There are several methods and they are all good, so choose the one that works best for you and produces the most consistent desired outcome.
There are three key elements in creating the perfect steak. The cut of meat, the thickness of the meat, and heat. The New York Strip and the Filet are my favorite cuts, followed by the Flat Iron and the Ribeye. There are a few other cuts worth grilling, but these four will suit most anyone’s palate. I prefer steaks that are close to the one to one and a half inch range give or take. Going thicker than that and getting consistent results is an art, and going significantly thinner makes it difficult to both get a crust and not have a well done steak. The exception seems to be the Flat Iron which can produce both a recognizable sear and a medium rare temperature with a thinner cut. Lastly high heat; you must have a high heat source either at the beginning or end of the cook to create that mouthwatering perfect steak.
Once you have sourced and acquired that steak, you have to prepare it. My philosophy is that less is better, no need to over season that steak. I rub a very small amount of oil on both sides, and I generally only use salt and pepper. I have added a few variations at the end of the recipe. You also want to let the steak come close to room temperature before it hits the cooking surface. You can do this while you are preparing any side dishes or other parts of the meal.
Now it is time to cook that steak! You can cook this meal inside or outside. Most of my meat recipes are based on an outdoor grill cook, but I will also add the variation to bring it indoors when possible if an outdoor grill is not an option. I have also added cooking surface variations, and cooking method variations at the end of the recipe.
Last key element is internal temperature of the meat. Use a meat thermometer for most consistent outcomes.
- Rare 125
- Medium Rare 130
- Medium 140
- Medium Well 150
And don’t forget to let that steak rest before serving
Preparation Time: 20 minutes
Servings: 5
Ingredients:
5 steaks approximately 1 to 1 1/2 inches thick
Olive Oil
Sea Salt
Pepper
Directions:
Rub each steak lightly with oil and season with salt and pepper taste
Bring Grill up to or near 500 degrees
Cook steak on both sides 1 to 2 minutes to allow a charred crust to form.
Turn frequently and move to cooler part of the grill as needed until desired internal temperature is reached.
Remove from Grill and let rest 5 to 10 minutes before serving
Enjoy!
Cooking Variations:
Stove Top
Heat Skillet and follow directions above, remove from heat as needed until internal temperature is reached.
Reverse Sear
Cook on 300 to 350 degree Grill until within 10 to 15 degrees of desired internal temperature. Remove from Grill and raise temperature on Grill to around 500 degrees. Sear steak on both sides.
One Turn Method
Cook steak on one side until within 10 to 15 degrees of desired internal temperature. Turn steak and cook and until desired internal temperature is reached.
Cast Iron Method(Outdoor Only)
Place Cast Iron Pan on Grill and use as cooking surface
I prefer the Lodge brand
Recipe Variations:
Seasoning
Add any of the following:
Garlic
Onion Powder
Tumeric
Toppings
Sauteed Mushrooms and/or Onions
A pat of butter
Marinade
Soak in coffee 8 to 24 hours